Thoughts on Anabaptists and Dunker Punks

This weekend, I got to attend a conference called “Church and Post-Chrsitian Culture: Christian Witness in the Way of Jesus.” It was a conference hosted by Missio Alliance that focused on the convergence of evangelical and anabaptist thought and how we apply that theology to the concept of mission. That’s a lot of opaque jargon for asking: “How do we follow Jesus?” and “How and why do we encourage others to follow Jesus?”

In the coming weeks, I’ll be writing several blog posts about what I learned and experienced that I found particularly meaningful or thought-provoking, but first, two takeaways for me from the conference as a whole:

1. As anabaptists, we have a beautiful tradition and heritage that we don’t always understand, appreciate, or use.

This is especially true for people like me who grew up anabaptist. Many of the speakers at the conference were actually “outsiders,” people who grew up in a different faith tradition and either came to identify as Anabaptists through prayer and study, or don’t identify as anabaptists but admire and use our theology to inform the way they follow Jesus.

Jarrod McKenna talked about this at NYC. He mentioned that the world is watching us. The world is studying and learning about our tradition, using it to shape their own beliefs and practices. He also mentioned, though, that we have grown up in this thing that the world is just now trying to emulate, and we don’t even understand it ourselves.

That’s why he challenged us to take up this Dunker Punks way of life. As Dunker Punks we must continually strive to learn more about how our faith ancestors followed Jesus. This means praying the Lord’s Prayer as seriously and faithfully as they did, reading the love and teachings of Jesus as deeply and enthusiastically as they did, and living out our faith as radically as they did.

2. Far more importantly, its all about Jesus.

Here’s a tweet that says it better than I can:

This starts with we in the Church of the Brethren admitting that Alexander Mack didn’t found our faith, Jesus did.

And we Dunker Punks must realize that Jarrod McKenna isn’t the impetus of our movement, Jesus is.

Alexander Mack and Jarrod McKenna put these things into words, got them going, got us excited about them. They are amazing, intelligent, thoughtful, and helpful people that can help us understand how to follow Jesus. But we must be careful to never worship our heritage, traditions, or theology. Only Jesus.

It’s ok to be excited, maybe even proud, of our tradition. But our tradition, and this Dunker Punks movement, is only valuable so far as it leads us to more faithfully follow Jesus.

That’s what being a Dunker Punk is all about. It’s to identify with the roots of our tradition, which elevate Jesus, compel us to follow Jesus, and inspire us to view everything the we do — the way we read scripture, the way we interact with others, the way we practice our religion– through the lens of Jesus. It’s about making space in our lives by studying, praying, and gathering together. It’s about making things less about ourselves, and more about Jesus.

It’s starts be realizing that:
reading the bible,
doing justice,
building peace,
living radical, ordinary, peculiar, simple lives…

Are all smaller pieces that fit into the larger context of following Jesus.

One of my favorite descriptions of Jesus comes at the beginning of Hebrews 12. The writer of Hebrews calls Jesus “the author and perfecter of our faith.”

Let Jesus be the author and perfecter of your faith. Not Alexander Mack or Jarrod McKenna. Not your pastor. Not your friends or family. Certainly not me. Of course, use people to enhance and grow in your understanding of how to follow Jesus.

But keep Jesus at the center and permeated through everything that you do.

Emmett Eldred - Hollidaysburg COB, Middle PA District

Emmett Eldred is a sophomore Creative Writing; Professional Writing; and Ethics, History, and Public Policy Major at Carnegie Mellon University. His passions include reading about, writing about, and snuggling with pugs. Emmett is the founder of, and he wants lots more people to contribute! Fill out a Dunker Punks profile, and join the conversation! Follow Emmett on twitter @emmetteldred and follow Dunker Punks on Twitter @DunkerPunks and on Facebook

2 thoughts on “Thoughts on Anabaptists and Dunker Punks

  1. Jessi says:

    Yes, I so agree. As someone who grew up outside of anabaptism, but married into a family deeply rooted in it’s heritage, I struggle greatly with appreciation of it as a theological position, but wrestle with the way it can take over as a culture of it’s own. It feels beyond ‘separate’ in what could be a healthy way, and often crosses over the line into ‘elitist’. My hope is that as there is a resurgence of many of the values and understanding of scripture on the points unique to anabaptism that there can also be an embracing of others who bring differing strengths and understandings from their unique positions in the kingdom. I missed the final speakers of the conference, sadly, but it sounds like much of this embracing perspective was brought up. It is wonderfully encouraging to see conversation happening between various theological ‘camps’, and exploring how we can all lend our strengths to the mission of the Gospel, and a fresh awareness of Jesus as Lord of it all!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s